Corsi Rosenthal Box vs. Air Purifier: Which One Do You Actually Need?

You've seen it in a classroom, a coworking space, maybe your neighbor's garage: a box fan like Lasko taped on top of 4 furnace filters. It looks like a science fair project (it sort of is). And it works.
So if you're weighing a Corsi Rosenthal box vs. an air purifier for your home, office, or classroom, here are the considerations.
What is a Corsi-Rosenthal (CR) box?
A Corsi-Rosenthal box (also called a CR cube or Comparetto Cube) is a DIY air cleaner that pairs a powerful box fan with relatively high-flow MERV13 or MERV14 furnace filters. It's named after UC Davis professor Dr. Richard Corsi and Tex-Air Filters CEO Jim Rosenthal, who popularized the design in 2020 when so many schools were trying to reopen after pandemic closures and attempt to reduce the risk of airborne infection transmission. Those filters catch at least 77% (MERV13) or 88% (MERV14) of virus-sized particles and fine particulate (PM2.5) per pass.
The CDC even discusses DIY air cleaners in its ventilation guidance, which recommends aiming for at least 5 air changes per hour (ACH) of clean air in occupied indoor spaces. We now know that 6-12+ air changes per hour are ideal for the reduction of person-to-person airborne illness transmission. Another guideline is the ASHRAE 241 guidelines that tell us classrooms need 40 cubic feet per minute (cfm) of Clean Air Delivery Rate (CADR) to meaningfully reduce that risk. (Spoiler: most crowded classrooms only need two of our Luggable XLs to achieve that standard vs. several conventional air purifiers it would take to cover 25 kids and a teacher.)
Why high airflow outperforms "99.97% HEPA efficiency"
Most air purifiers are sold on one number: the 99.97% per-pass efficiency of a HEPA filter. Sounds better than 77%, right? But what really matters is how much clean air gets into your room, and how fast. That's measured as Clean Air Delivery Rate (CADR).
A MERV13 filter with a lot of air moving through it can clear a room faster than a HEPA filter behind a tiny-yet-loud fan, because the air makes more passes through the filter. Some experiments even suggest CR boxes catch more per pass at lower fan speeds than the typical HEPA purifier.
Comparing numbers for Corsi Rosenthal box vs. air purifier
Performance and energy usage
A CR box with 4 filters on low speed delivers approximately 300-450 CADR, depending on fan model and filter brand. Higher with our favorite filter brand: Filtrete. But lower these days after the more powerful box fans like Honeywell were discontinued that could top out at 800 CADR on the highest speed. With the most widely available option, Lasko, you can get 400 cfm on speed 1. More on this below, but be aware that even speed 1 might be too loud for some people’s preferences or settings. Energy usage is 50-85 watts.
Our Purifying Table, Luggable, Luggable XL, and Brisk Box Ultra Black cover that same 300-450 CADR range using 10-16W. That's about a quarter of the electricity (or less). And our 4-fan Brisk Box is very close at 260 cfm, but it’s a consistent speed that won’t get turned down or unplugged since it’s incredibly quiet.
Noise
A CR box’s sound levels are 55 to 65 dB depending on the fan speed setting. For context, 45 dB is the unofficial standard believed to be the maximum volume tolerated in classroom settings.
The CleanAirKits purifiers deliver their high CADR at 39-48 dB. A 10 dB drop in noise actually sounds roughly half as loud to your ears.
Cost
CR Box: $25 (Lasko box fan) + $100 (four 20”x20”x1” MERV 13 filters) + $5 (white duct tape) = $130
Yearly cost = $100-$200 for filters
PC-fan more sustainable versions of the CR Box (or as we like to call it, Next Gen CR Box): $159-$434 for the kit + $34-$68 for filters = $193-$502.
|
Noise |
Cost |
Performance |
|
|
Corsi Rosenthal Box |
Noticeably loud |
300-450 CADR |
|
|
Clean Air Kits Air Purifiers |
Quiet |
300-450 CADR 10-16 watts |
So which one should you use?
-
Build a CR box if you're on a tighter budget, need a LOT of clean air fast, and noise isn't an issue. They’re great for gyms, workshops, or empty rooms you want to clear out after a gathering. They’re also really helpful in an emergency–isolating a sick household member or a wildfire or urban smoke event.
-
Go with a purifier like the CleanAirKits Luggable XL, Purifying Table, or Purifying Prism if you'll be in the room with it--a bedroom, classroom, office, or anywhere people need to talk, sleep, or hear themselves think. If you have sensory auditory issues, quiet PC-fan builds are usually non-negotiable. Same clean air, quieter, and much cheaper to run all day. For a similar cost, with a much lower sound level but also lower CADR, you can use our 3-fan Brisk Box or 3-fan Purifying Prism (also a smaller footprint than the 20”x20” CR Boxes).
We're big fans (sorry) of the filter box movement. It got clean air into a lot of schools that otherwise wouldn't have had any, and there are still initiatives like the one UConnIAQ is doing for Connecticut schools trying to get them into even more classrooms. We’ve also supported the Corsi Rosenthal Foundation for years. But if you need clean air you can actually live with all day or teach with all day without having to adjust the sound levels, that's what we built ours for.